The Spirit: The New Adventures – Cursed Beauty (#5) – Paul Chadwick

3 out of 5

As I haven’t read much of Eisner’s The Spirit, I can’t say wholeheartedly how much each of the contributors to these ‘New Adventures’ properly capture the, er, essence of the original, but the crop of creatives that’ve worked onto this title up to this point do seem like exactly the types to know how to balance tribute with an update.

Paul Chadwick, in Concrete, had well proven by this point his ability to float between some pulp elements, dense thrills and drama, and even some soap – all of which feels like a good pitch reel for The Spirit. And his ‘The Case of Cursed Beauty’ exactly tries to interweave most of that, making sure to nod to Eisner’s femme fatales while also doing his best to navigate through some needed social critiques – on sidekick Ebony White; on femme fatales in general… In that navigation, Chadwick isn’t entirely successful. I respect, in Concrete, that Paul will take some big topical swings and feel comfortable not trying to put an answer on them (while also not trying to cast himself / his characters in the best of lights), and there’s some of that here as well. However, Concrete benefitted from being something of an ongoing – threads Paul could pick up and pluck along the way; there’s just 20something pages to achieve that in this instance, and it’s not enough.

The core mystery necessarily stumbles a bit as well, since it feels like both an aside to these other explorations and then rushed for conclusions in some spots – visualized by some clunky layouts – but Paul does otherwise stick with the conventions of a pulp / Spirit story structure, and his balance of stylized characters and scene detailing is highlighted well in John Nyberg’s delicate inks and Angus McKie’s poppy colors.

In ‘Cursed Beauty,’ The Spirit investigates the cause of a dead body found in a hotel, tracking down a woman seen fleeing the scene in only a trenchcoat… The overall execution is definitely overstuffed, but Paul’s art is lovely, and the story feels like a proper Spirit update, even if some of the particulars are less than stellar.