Pelican – For Your Entertainment / Gasoline

3 out of 5

Label: Numero Group

Produced by: Sanford Parker (recorded by)

A limited cassingle release of two covers – Unwound’s For Your Entertainment, and Karate’s Gasoline – both with vocals from Pinebender’s Chris Hansen.

Covers… hm. Covers can benefit from, like, being really awesome songs originally – and being a fan of the song in the first place – and then obviously how well your covering band wrangles that cover, and whether or not you are a follower of that covering band, and expect them to put their spin on it.

Pelican has wanted to ditch their metal and instrumental rock labels for forever, and I’m the type of fan who’s struggled with their struggles, somewhat put off by when they stray too far from whatever my idealized version of the band sounds like (i.e. their first EP), so while I conceptually get them wanting to cover some classic indie rock (and lord knows just because you are into genre A doesn’t mean you can’t be simultaneously into genre B), but I’m not so much a fan of Karate, and not not a fan of Unwound, but certainly not a follower.

In trying to equate for all of that and give as honest a review as possible for this single, I’d still give it a shoulder shrug: certainly if you like these originals, there’s something to hearing them covered, though the Karate track “benefits” more from getting a Pelican makeover with heavier guitar work and the melody being highlighted via the band playing the track faster than the original, while the Unwound cover is pretty true to form – meaning nothing much added – save the changeup in vocals. There’s the collectability factor, of course, leaving me somewhere in the middle on the rating. These are solid, generally unflashy covers.

Adding my bias back in, I think Hansen’s deeper vocal pitch versus Geoff Farina’s emo wheedle works well enough, but man, it feels weird knowing that Pelican plays this faster, and the guitar drop kinda feels like a cheap “remember we’re that metal band that doesn’t like being called metal” move; I actually think the Karate version hits a ton harder.

For Your Entertainment, as mentioned, doesn’t really add to or take away from the original, which then means… why not listen to the original.

…But I’ll leave the rating as representative of the less snarked up take that has to accept people are only buying this as fans of one band or the other, and likely less so as a listener like me, who keeps listening and hoping for an experience the band isn’t interested in any more.