2 out of 5
Bit by bit these aren’t bad stories, but read in a batch it’s a lot of “filler” (one or two-part stories that just do the job and get out) and includes enough underwhelming or cringey thrills to make this an easy skip in a collection or Dredd readthrough.
The 2000 ADs feature a roundhouse of amazing artists – John Burns, Kevin Walker, Alex Ronald, Henry Flint, just to name a few – but because of the relative shortness of each thrill, the visuals change so frequently that it adds to the sensation of the stories just bouncing around, and not really hanging around long enough to make an impact.
And just to make a quick aside to those statements: short thrills are absolutely fine, and can be great, but there’s a version of that that can also read like an Archie comic book, or Sunday comix gags: entertaining, though written to almost purposefully standalone, disposable gags. Apply that to a Dredd oner as you will.
The few multi-part stories we get are sometimes artist mismatches (Calum Alexander Watts’ Spooks has trouble establishing tone) or revel too much in Wagner’s more unpleasantly humored side (e.g. the lots of vomit in Fast Food), but Missing, which closes out the collection, is at least one of the best strips of the set (if also reminiscent of Wagner’s Chain Gang War).
While inconsequential, this stuff would mostly be an okay read, but what drags it down a little bit more are the Meg entries, which feature the complete misfire Ojay (such an obvious parody with such lack of bite), and then… the Predator vs. Judge Dredd reprint, which is a fine thing on its own as printed outside of 2000 AD and aimed at US audiences, but feels cheap – if accurate – as an inclusion here. Like, it’s a copy of a copy: this trade copying the meg, which copied the original comic. And because this isn’t the UK Dredd, and yet it was published without the “alternate universe” banner of some of the later movie-universe Dredd strips, I find myself really annoyed by reading it after the actual Dredd stuff.
P vs JD is a fun concept, but Wagner wrote it for Americans who needed hints about how the Judges operated, and what Mega-city was, and so on. This already reads hinkily, and then you get to Dredd’s ‘tude, which is much more in the vein of the Stallone shouty one-liners Dredd. So, like, I get it; and I am accepting of it when it’s printed as a separate series. However, irony of the same guy writing all of this aside, the Predator vs. Judge Dredd Joe just ain’t my Joe.
A very uneven collection overall, featuring nothing that necessarily endured outside of these stories, and the back 1/5th or so being dedicated to a Judge Dredd who doesn’t read at all like the character you otherwise know.